April 16, 2005

Not Your Grandma. Rather, an Insidious Species of Vermin

Here's a whole website dedicated to demonstrating "the futility of using Microsoft Word's spelling and grammar check." I doubt that this really needed demonstrating, in fact, but for what it's worth I think we can consider it demonstrated.

According to this article, the university professor who runs the site believes that the grammar-checker should be improved so that it actually prevents his students' grammar errors. I believe this would be a terrible mistake. The last thing we need is for some misguided technician to make the grammar checker more powerful.

I think MS should just reveal the closely guarded secret of how to turn it off so it stays turned off, which is something I've never been able to achieve with complete consistency. The grammar checker has a life and mind of its own, and really seems to resent being left out of the writing process. As soon as you start trying to turn it off, it begins scheming to hang on. It is stronger and more determined than you, and has a longer attention span. You may win a couple of battles along the way, but it has all the time in the world. Eventually, no matter what you do, it will manage to switch itself back on, and taunt you with squiggly green lines and by changing random lower case letters to capital letters and vice versa, and arbitrarily inserting bizarre formatting when you're not looking. At some point, you will get old and die. The grammar checker will still be there. Laughing.

Exterminate it, and the world really would be a better place. But I'm not going to hold my breath.

Posted by Dr. Frank at April 16, 2005 06:40 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Man, I hate it when people make me use Microsoft products, or MS-like products.

I typeset all my crap in TeX, using the vi editor. In fact I'd rather do it in TeX than LaTeX, since you have more control, but sometimes you have to yield to the reality of the situation.

No spell checker (well there is but it's a separate program and you have to invoke it manually), no damn grammar checker, no prisoners, no mercy. Do it right or die, weakling.

Posted by: Angie Schultz at April 17, 2005 06:16 PM

I have noticed that the MS Grammar Checker has often "corrected" my grammar to promote incorrect usage, particularly with the "it's/its", "they're, their, there" and "you're/your" usages. It also makes mistakes with noun-verb conjugation agreements. If the MS utility is going to correct your grammar, couldn't it at least do it correctly?

Posted by: Elizabeth at April 18, 2005 04:30 AM

Elizabeth, I think the MSW grammar checker just wants to make an impact on the document, for good or ill, regardless of what may or not be correct. It craves the spotlight, like Lucy trying to sneak on stage at the Cabana Club: even if she can't quite do the right dance steps, and has to wear a ridiculous false mustache that fools no one, at least she's up there. The grammar checker doesn't care if it ruins the show, as long as its voice is heard.

Posted by: Dr. Frank at April 18, 2005 04:51 AM

I never understood why anyone would like Lucy. Not the show but the person. She was always screwing up stuff that she had no buisiness messing with in the first place. She was whiny and, dare I say, kind of dumb. The only cool guy on that show was Fred. All tv charachters are based on Fred you know. ALL OF THEM.

Posted by: Mark at April 18, 2005 03:27 PM

If you really want to disable the grammar tool for good, remove it from the Shared Applications: Proofing Tools folder, in the Microsoft Office folder. It won't keep you from using Word. If you try to use the grammar tool, it will just tell you it can't be found. I pulled everything out of the folder that had to do with spelling and grammar and Word worked fine. I don't know how to deal with AutoCorrect, however. But maybe with spelling and grammar gone, it will be less of a hassle.

I just use Adobe InCopy instead because that UI is just more familiar to me. More hospitable. No stupid cartoon, when I access the help files.

Posted by: jodi at April 18, 2005 03:52 PM

Jodi, that's the first useful tip I've had in a long career of trying to solicit useful tips on this subject. I'm glad it works for you, though I'm going to have to see it with my own eyes before I believe it: my sense is that that grammar checker will somehow figure out a way to migrate back to the proper folder, or perhaps recopy itself. It has a strong survival instinct. Whatever doesn't kill it makes it stronger. Maybe the thing to do is not just move it, and not just delete it, but also rename it, break it into segments, and write the segments over with zeroes and random characters for around 100 passes.

I admit, though, I think of the Grammar Checker as my white whale, but there are other pernicious tools and wizards to deal with, and they get mixed up in my mind. I always thought of autocorrect as an arm of the GC, since it seems to try to correct supposed grammatical errors. But now I realize it's more like a minion of all the tools, rushing in to carry out their orders. It sure is irritating, whatever it is. Sometimes it's like playing a video game, where I'll keep hitting backspace and retyping, and the autorcorrector refuses to die, until eventually I forget what I was going to write and close the file.

Posted by: Dr. Frank at April 18, 2005 05:25 PM

i personally like the MS spell check/grammar check because it makes me feel smug about humanity. do they really think they can programme all the subtleties and intracacies of language into a computer? language is such a fluid undefined thing, it seems ridiculous to even try. but then again, i'm the type who loves to pick fights with neo-grammarians. they're worse than neo-cons.

Posted by: kendra at April 18, 2005 05:27 PM


curse those green squigglys... curse them!
(insert Homer Simpson fist)

Posted by: just me at April 18, 2005 08:12 PM

My MS Word story: I was writing a paper on the French Revolution for my World History class. As you may or may not know, July 14th is the French equivalent of July 4th. Wonderful, lovely, MS Word Spell Check changed every instance of July 14th, to July 4th, losing me points and making me look like a fool.

Posted by: MandaMagpie at April 18, 2005 09:45 PM

If you're really and truly having difficulty turning the grammar/spell checker off permanently, my SO (who works with this stuff for a living) says you need to do it in Preferences. (You can also teach it to ignore specific "wrongly spelled" words, such as names. It's the first thing my daughter does, as her own name gets flagged. Personally, I don't use Word much, so I just ignore it.) If you have trouble finding where to do it, I can tell you. I just need to know if you're on a Mac or a PC.

Posted by: robin at April 19, 2005 01:10 AM

well, I'm just so happy that I was useful in some capacity today, since I spent my workday in meeting after meeting after meeting. The problem is, you need to write code to permanently kill AutoCorrect. What kind of code is beyond my ken.

Posted by: jodi at April 19, 2005 02:10 AM

Per http://word.mvps.org/FAQs/Formatting/TameAutoFormat.htm

here is the coding for a macro that you can run when word opens.

"
Sub AutoExec()

With Dialogs(wdDialogToolsOptionsGeneral)
.WPHelp = 0
.WPDocNavKeys = 0
.Execute
End With

With AutoCorrect
.CorrectInitialCaps = True
.CorrectDays = True
.CorrectCapsLock = True
.ReplaceText = True
End With

With Options
.UpdateLinksAtPrint = True
.PrintDrawingObjects = True
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeApplyHeadings = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeApplyBorders = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeApplyBulletedLists = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeApplyNumberedLists = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeApplyTables = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeReplaceQuotes = True
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeReplaceSymbols = True
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeReplaceOrdinals = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeReplacePlainTextEmphasis = True
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeFormatListItemBeginning = False
.AutoFormatAsYouTypeDefineStyles = False
.AutoFormatApplyHeadings = False
.AutoFormatApplyLists = False
.AutoFormatApplyBulletedLists = False
.AutoFormatApplyOtherParas = False
.AutoFormatReplaceQuotes = True
.AutoFormatReplaceSymbols = True
.AutoFormatReplaceOrdinals = False
.AutoFormatReplacePlainTextEmphasis = False
.AutoFormatPreserveStyles = True
.AutoFormatPlainTextWordMail = True
End With

End Sub
"

Per http://users.telenet.be/solvenet/word1.htm#AUTOMATICALLYEXECUTING

Naming your
macro Autoexec when you create it (by selecting Tools, Macro, then entering the name in the Macro Name text box) is your way of telling Word 2000 to run the macro whenever Word launches.


Also as a reference you may want to check out
http://www.tutorialized.com/tutorials/MS-Word/Macros/1

That is all I could come up with, but hopefully one of those works for you .

Posted by: jason at April 19, 2005 02:36 AM

http://www.craigslist.org/about/best/chi/68374006.html

Posted by: sheckie at April 19, 2005 07:41 PM

I deleted my Spell/Grammar Check only to find out that it had been sent back in time to kill my mom in the late '70s. It cannot be stopped.

Posted by: lucky409 at April 20, 2005 02:58 PM